• Share. Be Supported. Recover.

    We are a friendly, safe community supporting each other's mental health. We are open 24 hours a day, 365 days a year.

Formally schizophrenia

firemonkey

firemonkey

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 12, 2008
Messages
131
Location
Southend on sea
The February edition of the British Journal of Psychiatry has a thought-provoking editorial by psychiatrist Jim van Os, arguing that we should reject the diagnosis of schizophrenia owing to its lack of validity and replace it with a concept of a 'salience dysregulation syndrome'.

If you're not familiar with the use of the term salience, it is used widely in cognitive science to describe the attention grabbing quality of things and psychosis is widely thought to involve, at least in part, a problem with the regulation of salience so normally unremarkable things seem important or alarming.

Although this idea has been kicked around for many years, it was popularised in recent years by an influential article by psychiatrist Shitij Kapur called 'Psychosis as a state of aberrant salience', as differences in dopamine function are regularly found in studies on delusions and hallucinations.

Importantly, disturbance in dopamine-regulated salience does not seem specific to schizophrenia, but is common across all psychotic disorders.

Consequently, van Os reviews the scientific literature that has repeatedly found that the diagnosis of schizophrenia does not seem to be a cut-and-dry category and that psychosis appears in various forms to differing degrees throughout the population.

He particularly argues for the importance of explicitly naming the problem as a 'syndrome', as despite that fact that most people accept that it is not a single disorder, it can get treated as such simply out of habit:

First, although criticisms about the diagnostic construct of schizophrenia may be deflected with the argument that it is merely a syndrome (the association of several clinically recognisable features that often occur together for which a specific disorder may or may not be identified as the underlying cause), the problem is that its very name and the way mental health professionals use and communicate about the term results in medical reification and validation through professional behaviour rather than scientific data, exposing psychiatry to ridicule and hampering scientific progress. It may be argued, therefore, that if it is a syndrome, calling it as such may serve to remind professionals (and downstream of these, the rest of the world) of the relatively agnostic state of science in this regard.

Second, given the fact that maximum utility in terms of conveying clinical information may be obtained by combining categorical with dimensional representations of psychopathology, DSM–V and ICD–11 may be best served by creating separate categorical and dimensional axes of the psychopathology of psychotic disorders.
 

Attachments

Rambuie Perspecador

Rambuie Perspecador

Well-known member
Founding Member
Joined
Dec 21, 2007
Messages
338
Location
Nottingham
2 difficulties I have with this right away. Firstly I wonder from whose perspectives schizophrenia can be thought to have a lack of validity! It would be exceedingly cruel to people with Bi Polar diagnosis to have no distinction or blur the distinction made with their brand of psychosis and the nature in which schizophrenia presents - especially as the treatments available for the distinctive diagnoses are so at variance with each other! Great Indignation and contempt is elicited from the Bi Polar people when the atypicals are served upon them - and I would be equally disgusted with administrations of Lithium, for instance. We need to have some deference for the fact that Clinicans are trying to do a job here, that will continue to serve acutely ill people as best they can - and at least not to render them the disservice that is suggested here.

Secondly 'salience' serves judgment upon people who are themselves trying to make sense of it all, and to so judge people that whatever people express during their times of distress that it is dysregulated or inappropriate - whatever - is grossly insensitive and damaging to the spirit - as damaging as calling us deviants or 'abnormal' - whatever that is supposed to mean.

However I do respect the earnestness of the spirit in which this is raised and my short comment would be 'nice try'. :)
 
Libra1

Libra1

Well-known member
Founding Member
Joined
Jan 12, 2008
Messages
515
Location
West Midlands
Rambuie - a bit off topic, but are you a 'medic' in MHS ? :)
 
Rambuie Perspecador

Rambuie Perspecador

Well-known member
Founding Member
Joined
Dec 21, 2007
Messages
338
Location
Nottingham
No chance! I learn stuff the hard way - its quite usual for a 'patient' to want a cure more than a Clinician so a Patient throws his or her weight behind whatever will achieve that. Desperate times... :(
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
E Did you get told your diagnosis or was it implied for a long time before you were formally diagnosed? Schizophrenia Forum 10
S Can the progression of schizophrenia be slowed down or delayed with treatment/medication? I need treatment right now. I also have anhedonia. Schizophrenia Forum 6
S Should I tell them I have mental illness/depression or schizophrenia? Schizophrenia Forum 13
O Schizophrenia or Someone from Above Schizophrenia Forum 1
P People with schizophrenia who work Schizophrenia Forum 20
L Nothing whatsoever to do with schizophrenia Schizophrenia Forum 17
nenexx I CANT LIVE LIKE THIS, IS THIS SCHIZOPHRENIA? or what HELP ME Schizophrenia Forum 18
O Is it Schizophrenia or is it Someone From Above? Schizophrenia Forum 2
slowturtle Paranoid Schizophrenia Schizophrenia Forum 1
L did your schizophrenia Schizophrenia Forum 22
L Does your schizophrenia Schizophrenia Forum 6
nenexx Is this schizophrenia? Schizophrenia Forum 16
C What if schizophrenia has something to do with your spirit/higher self/soul/subconscious mind? Schizophrenia Forum 19
M Is that a sign to get schizophrenia? Schizophrenia Forum 16
MissPink Has my boyfriend got Schizophrenia? Schizophrenia Forum 5
O Clozapine for Schizophrenia is Great Schizophrenia Forum 5
lifecangetbetter suggestions for a job with someone with schizophrenia Schizophrenia Forum 2
S My cousin has schizophrenia Schizophrenia Forum 11
S Schizophrenia and Spravato Schizophrenia Forum 6
veela Schizophrenia and work Schizophrenia Forum 12
P I am so confused (schizophrenia / schizoaffective/bipolar) Schizophrenia Forum 2
M Happy Productive life despite schizophrenia Schizophrenia Forum 1
M when to tell someone you are dating you have schizophrenia Schizophrenia Forum 7
T Schizophrenia vs anxiety induced psychosis Schizophrenia Forum 2
S Schizophrenia and adhd Schizophrenia Forum 3
H How did you first know you had schizophrenia? Schizophrenia Forum 3
BEASTMODEWARRIOR Schizophrenia: Stigma and Challenges Schizophrenia Forum 55
L autism and schizophrenia Schizophrenia Forum 2
Tawny Eastenders story line - Schizophrenia Schizophrenia Forum 25
S Could it be schizophrenia Schizophrenia Forum 13
BEASTMODEWARRIOR Guys i think i have unlock some super powers from schizophrenia idk? Schizophrenia Forum 12
Amelia2020 I think i might have Schizophrenia Schizophrenia Forum 2
B Dating someone with Schizophrenia Schizophrenia Forum 2
vangoghs Dating with Schizophrenia Schizophrenia Forum 21
BEASTMODEWARRIOR Everyday i learn more about my own schizophrenia, i learn more how to battle it and understand it and see it as it is? Schizophrenia Forum 2
nenexx Do I have schizophrenia or is it anxiety? Schizophrenia Forum 28
nenexx potential "cure" for schizophrenia Schizophrenia Forum 9
S Countdown and schizophrenia Schizophrenia Forum 5
R That Demon: Schizophrenia Schizophrenia Forum 8
L Do You find schizophrenia Schizophrenia Forum 4
lifecangetbetter Klonopin for schizophrenia, any luck? Schizophrenia Forum 4
vangoghs Historical Figures with Schizophrenia Schizophrenia Forum 5
ht46 Schizophrenia impairs your thinking Schizophrenia Forum 14
P Keep thinking I have a schizophrenia psychosis Schizophrenia Forum 19
vangoghs My experience with schizophrenia. Is yours similar in any way? Schizophrenia Forum 9
I Possibly schizophrenia- hearing voices Schizophrenia Forum 12
L schizophrenia Schizophrenia Forum 12
Mr.NiceGuy Schizophrenia cause Schizophrenia Forum 6
S Dear schizophrenia patient. Schizophrenia Forum 20
T Idk if I even have paranoid schizophrenia Schizophrenia Forum 1

Similar threads

Top